This Article performs a close analysis of workers’ compensation coverage of COVID-19 and arrives at the conclusion that it should not be “impossible” to prove in a legal sense that an employee’s COVID-19 was caused by work. Scientific proof is not the same as legal proof: Workers’ compensation law has never required that claims must be supported by irrefutable scientific proof of workplace causation. Yet repeatedly one heard this suggestion during public discussion on workers’ compensation coverage of employees.
Still, there is good evidence that even when workers’ compensation undisputedly covers work-related disease, employers seldom pay benefits and states do not compel them to do so. This is one reality that COVID-19 laid bare: The workers’ compensation system rigidly resists paying occupational disease claims. This Article also explores a news account from Minnesota stating that 935 of 935 workers’ compensation COVID-19-related claims from meatpacking employees had not been paid as of February 2021. There was no shortage of other stories during the pandemic of mass denial of workers’ compensation claims in the meatpacking industry, a development having a disparate impact on communities of color, where more than half of all meatpacking employees are Latinx. These unpaid claim numbers suggest that something was “wrong” with causation analyses at the lower levels of the administrative system.
Another truth COVID-19 laid bare is that, aside from workers’ compensation, there is no nationwide short-term disability program in the United States. This leads to the conclusion that, if workers’ compensation insists upon super-strict versions of causation to cover claims, a different method of compensating short-term disability during pandemics or other “environmental” crises may become necessary. The conclusion seems almost inescapable because public health experts like Dr. Anthony Fauci are warning that we remain at risk for “new disease emergences” for the “foreseeable future.”
Michael C. Duff,
What COVID-19 Laid Bare: Adventures in Workers’ Compensation Causation,
San Diego L. Rev.
Available at: https://digital.sandiego.edu/sdlr/vol59/iss2/3